Updated:

A Button Is Not Always Consent: Ninth Circuit Rejects Streaming Arbitration Clause

On 5 November 2026, the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit issued an unpublished memorandum in Morrison v. Yippee Entertainment, Inc., No. 25-7161, affirming the denial of a streaming company’s motion to compel arbitration in a putative class action under the Video Privacy Protection Act. The dispute concerned a subscription sign-up page that stated users agreed to the terms by “clicking below”. But several clickable links appeared below that statement, alongside the “Start Subscription” button. The panel concluded that the wording did not clearly identify which action manifested assent to the arbitration clause. The court therefore declined to treat the page as establishing an enforceable arbitration agreement. The underlying claim alleges disclosure of a subscriber’s personally identifiable information to a third party; the appellate decision addressed contract formation and arbitration, not the merits of the privacy claim. Importantly, the memorandum is expressly designated “not for publication” and is not precedential under the Ninth Circuit’s rules, except as those rules provide. It should be read as a fact-specific application of existing contract-formation principles, not as a categorical rule that online arbitration clauses are invalid.

In my view, the decision offers a practical lesson for every business that relies on sign-in-wrap or browse-wrap terms: a hyperlink may make terms available, but availability is not the same as affirmative and unambiguous agreement. I believe the critical drafting question is not merely whether a consumer could find the terms, but whether the interface tells the consumer, in plain language, exactly which action accepts them. A button labelled “Start Subscription” may communicate a commercial instruction; it does not necessarily cure an adjacent notice that ambiguously says “clicking below”. This distinction matters especially where arbitration, class-action waivers, recurring payments, data use, or other consequential provisions are embedded in standard terms. Product and legal teams should align the notice, the button label, the placement of links, and the recorded consent event; preserve a reliable version of the terms shown at the time; and test the flow on mobile as well as desktop. The broader point is not that every user must sign a paper contract. It is that digital convenience cannot substitute for proof of contractual assent. A carefully designed consent interface is both a compliance control and evidence of a valid agreement!

Source: Ninth Circuit, Morrison v. Yippee Entertainment, Inc., No. 25-7161, 5 November 2026; Mealey’s, 10 November 2026.