Puerto Rico's Top Court: Representing Yourself Does Not Excuse Fake Citations
Puerto Rico's Supreme Court fines two self-represented litigants for AI-linked fake authorities, extending lawyers' verification duty to everyone who files.

On 28 October 2026, the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico fined two siblings who were representing themselves in an inheritance dispute USD 500 each, after finding that their filings relied on roughly two dozen authorities that either did not exist or misdescribed the Court's own precedents, errors the justices linked to AI output that had never been checked. The litigants had gone pro se after their lawyer withdrew, resisted a trial-court order to retain counsel, and accused judicial officers of misconduct, including alleged tampering with a court recording; local press reports that the same pattern appeared at all three levels of the island's courts. Relying on Rules 9.4 and 44.2 of Puerto Rico's Rules of Civil Procedure, the Court held that the right of self-representation does not lift the duty to verify what one files, while stressing that AI itself is not banned: the line runs between using it as a drafting aid and submitting what it produces without confirmation. Coming after a series of sanctions against attorneys, the ruling matters because it extends the same accuracy duty to everyone who signs a court filing.
In my view the Court got the principle right and the sanction proportionate: a modest fine, a clear rule, and no technophobia. Fabricated authority wastes the time of judges and opponents regardless of who typed it! Yet I believe the decision exposes a gap it does not close. Self-represented parties are precisely the users most likely to depend on free, general-purpose chatbots, and the least equipped to verify their output; a fine after the fact punishes the symptom rather than preventing it. Courts that expect technological diligence from lay litigants should help supply it, through plain-language guidance, basic citation-checking support at the clerk's office, and perhaps a short certification that every cited case has actually been read. The practical lesson for lawyers and laypeople alike is simple: an authority you have not opened yourself is an authority you cannot cite!
Source: The San Juan Daily Star, 9 November 2026; El Nuevo Día, 14 November 2026




