Flag of Italy

On 14 November 2026, Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, fined Meta Platforms Ireland €805 million, about 0.47% of the group's worldwide turnover. The case concerns a Facebook for Android feature, available since 2023, that suggests photos and videos from the phone's gallery as ready-made posts. According to the Garante, gallery access for some 20 million Italian users was obtained through a single app-wide permission serving several functions, preceded by a generic "enable other features" notice that never mentioned gallery suggestions; once granted, the app could read the whole archive, metadata included, on an ongoing basis. As reported, the authority relied on Article 122 of the Italian Privacy Code, which implements the ePrivacy Directive, rather than the GDPR, and so rejected Meta's argument that Ireland's DPC should lead. Meta has 60 days to seek separate, specific consent and keep the feature off by default, even for users who already said yes. Meta will appeal and calls the fine disproportionate; possible AI training on gallery content was left outside the decision.

In my view, the decision's real strength is conceptual: the smartphone is part of the private sphere, so access itself needs informed consent, whether or not data leaves the device or harm follows. Equally important is the refusal to "grandfather" old yeses; a bundled consent does not become specific merely because time has passed! Yet I see two gaps. First, routing device access through national ePrivacy laws keeps platform exposure in Europe fragmented, which helps users today but invites inconsistent standards tomorrow. Second, the weightier question, a 2026 cloud feature that processes gallery content, is left for a separate inquiry. The practical lesson is simple: an operating-system permission is a technical switch, not a legal consent. I believe every app developer should map each device permission to one purpose, one notice and one off-by-default toggle, before a regulator does it for them!

Source: CX Today, 15 Nov 2026; ANSA, 14 Nov 2026